Convertible Note vs SAFE: What’s the Difference and Which Is Right for Your Startup?
Raising early-stage funding is a crucial milestone for any startup, but navigating the legal and financial instruments involved can be overwhelming — especially when choosing between a Convertible Note and a SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity).
Both are popular alternatives to traditional equity financing, particularly in pre-seed and seed rounds. They delay valuation discussions, streamline fundraising, and help startups grow quickly. But how do they actually differ?
Let’s break it down in plain English.
🔍 What Is a Convertible Note?
A convertible note is a short-term debt instrument that converts into equity (shares) during a future financing round — usually the next big equity round.
Key Features:
-
Treated as a loan (has interest & maturity date)
-
Converts into equity at a later round (usually with a discount or cap)
-
Often used when both sides want fast funding but aren't ready to value the company yet
Example:
An investor gives $100K to a startup. Instead of getting equity now, that money converts into shares during the next priced round — usually at a discount or with a valuation cap.
🔍 What Is a SAFE?
A SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity) is not a loan, but a promise to give equity in the future. It was introduced by Y Combinator in 2013 as a simpler, founder-friendly alternative to convertible notes.
Key Features:
-
No interest
-
No maturity date
-
Converts into equity during a future priced round (like a convertible note)
-
Clean, simple legal structure
Example:
An investor gives $100K using a SAFE with a $2M valuation cap. When the startup raises a priced round, the SAFE converts into shares — often at a better price than new investors.
🔄 Convertible Note vs SAFE: Key Differences
| Feature | Convertible Note | SAFE |
|---|---|---|
| Legal Type | Debt | Contract (not debt) |
| Interest Rate | Yes (typically 4–8%) | No |
| Maturity Date | Yes (usually 12–24 months) | No |
| Simplicity | Slightly complex (loan terms involved) | Extremely simple |
| Risk for Startup | Risk of repayment if not converted | No repayment pressure |
| Investor Comfort | More traditional, familiar to many VCs | Newer, some investors may prefer notes |
🔧 Shared Features
Despite their differences, both SAFEs and Convertible Notes often include:
-
Valuation Cap: Sets the maximum price at which the investment converts to equity.
-
Discount Rate: Gives early investors a better deal (e.g., 20% discount on next round’s share price).
-
Conversion Trigger: Typically happens during a priced equity round of a certain minimum size.
✅ Pros and Cons
Convertible Note Pros:
-
Familiar to many investors
-
Offers investor protection via debt structure
-
Can incentivize faster follow-up funding due to maturity date
Convertible Note Cons:
-
Adds complexity (interest, maturity)
-
Can cause pressure on founders if repayment is triggered
-
Requires more legal documentation
SAFE Pros:
-
Simpler and cheaper to execute
-
No interest or maturity deadline
-
Founder-friendly terms
SAFE Cons:
-
No built-in timeline for conversion
-
Some investors feel it lacks protections (especially in down rounds or delays)
-
Can cause dilution surprises if not managed carefully
📈 Which Should You Choose?
Use a SAFE if:
-
You want a simple, founder-friendly tool
-
You're raising small checks from many investors
-
Your investors are open to modern instruments (especially angels or accelerators)
Use a Convertible Note if:
-
Your investors prefer traditional terms
-
You want a maturity timeline to pressure future funding
-
You’re raising from institutional investors more familiar with debt instruments
🧠 Final Thoughts
Convertible Notes and SAFEs both offer fast, flexible ways to raise early funding without diving into complex valuation negotiations. The key is understanding your startup’s needs, investor expectations, and future financing plans.
TL;DR:
-
Want simplicity and founder-friendliness? Go with a SAFE.
-
Want structure and investor comfort? A Convertible Note might fit better.
Either way, always consult with a startup attorney before issuing either — small mistakes can have big implications down the road.
Comments
Post a Comment